OliveOil.com is now home to PJ KABOS Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Free US shipping on all orders!

Recipe: Greek Stuffed Tomatoes — "Domates Gemistes"—A Step-by-Step Visual Guide

Recipe: Greek Stuffed Tomatoes — "Domates Gemistes"—A Step-by-Step Visual Guide

Melanie Panagiotopoulou

Tomatoes are a culinary star in Modern Greece. Throughout the month of August, tractors pulling carts loaded with sun-ripened tomatoes on their way to canning factories is an often seen sight near the fields — the "kabos" — where PJ Kabos' historic family olive trees are located.

Meanwhile, across Greece, from Macedonia in the north to Crete in the south, and all the lands and islands in between, Domates Gemistes — Stuffed Tomatoes — made with fresh, ripe tomatoes, is the beloved dish that Greeks enjoy at the end of summer and then all year long.

Visual Recipe: Greek Stuffed Tomatoes—Domates Gemistes—with High-Phenolic Olive Oil

Main meal—Gemista and Ladera; Serves: 6; PJ KABOS High Phenolic Extra Virgin Olive Oil used: PJ Kabos Family Reserve Organic—Medium Taste 

Ingredients

  • 12 ripe tomatoes, medium size
  • 1 cup basmati rice, or whichever rice is preferred
  • 1 cup parsley, chopped
  • 2 medium onions, chopped
  • 2½ cups PJ Kabos Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • 1 cup water, cold
  • 1 teaspoon salt, plus some for sprinkling the potatoes and the inside of the tomatoes
  • ¼ teaspoon pepper, plus some for sprinkling the potatoes and the inside of the tomatoes
  • 12 slices feta cheese
  • ½ cup bread crumbs (optional)

For Serving

  • 3 cups strained Greek yogurt (optional); for vegan option, use tofu ‘yogurt’

Preparation

1) Over the bottom of a large baking pan spread 4 tablespoons of PJ Kabos Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

PJ Kabos EVOO being poured into a baking pan.
Good quality olive oil is a must for this dish.

2) Wash the tomatoes. Remove their tops, but keep them.

Tomatoes being prepared to make Greek Stuffed Tomatoes with rice.
Ripe tomatoes work best.

3) Scoop out the pulp from each tomato.

Tomatoes being readied for Stuffed tomatoes. Pulp being scooped out and the insides salted and peppered.
A grapefruit spoon works perfectly for this task.

4) Place each tomato, with its lid sitting next to it, in the prepared baking pan; the tomatoes sides should touch one another. Sprinkle the insides of each tomato with salt and pepper, to taste. Cover with kitchen paper and place in the refrigerator.

Scooped out tomatoes being placed in the baking pan and salted.
These tomatoes are all uniform in size, but ripe tomatoes often vary. Keep each lid next to its tomato for easy matching.

5) Place the tomato pulp and seeds in a large bowl or blender. Chop or blend until smooth, then chop and add the parsley.

Tomato pulp and parsley are key ingredients to making stuffed tomatoes.
Chopping the ingredients by hand or by using a blender gives a different texture to the dish. If time allows, try chopping by hand as our great-grandparents did—it’s worth the effort. In a pinch, use a blender for a quicker option that’s equally delicious!

6) Place a large pot, which has a cover, on the stove top; add 6 tablespoons of PJ Kabos Extra Virgin Olive Oil and slowly heat. Chop up the onions and lightly sauté in the pot.

Olive oil being used to sauté onions. It is totally safe an delicious!
Is olive oil safe for sautéing? Definitely yes! Click and read why.

7) Add the tomato pulp, parsley, salt, and pepper. Stir.

Tomato pulp being added to the sautéed onions in a fraying pan.
This is such a wonderful, savory meal—a true comfort food that brings the essence of the Mediterranean straight to your table.

8) Add the cold water and bring to a simmer. Add the rice. Cover and simmer on low until the rice is almost done. Taste the liquid and stir in more salt and pepper if desired. Let cool a bit.

Water and rice being added to the onion, tomato, parsley mix in the frying pan.
Different types of rice cook at varying speeds. Choose your favorite, but be sure to check the package for cooking instructions.

9) Meanwhile, clean and cut into large, bite size pieces three potatoes. Place in a bowl and sprinkle with salt and pepper. Coat the potatoes with 2 tablespoons of PJ Kabos Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

A chef cutting up a potato and then potatoes coated in olive oil.
Potatoes coated in olive oil turn golden and crisp when baked in the oven.

10) Filling the tomatoes: When sufficiently cooled (so you don’t burn your hands!) fill each tomato with the rice mixture, a little bit more than ¾ full.

The rice mixture being added to the waiting hollowed out tomatoes.
The rice continues to cook within the tomatoes while in the oven.

11) Place a slice of feta on the tops of each tomato. Cover with their tops. Place the potatoes among those tomatoes whose sides aren't touching. Carefully pour over all the tomatoes and potatoes 7 tablespoons of PJ Kabos Extra Virgin Olive Oil (or a little bit more!). Do not add extra water to the pan; the tomatoes have plenty.

Feta cheese being added to stuffed tomatoes.
The feta may also be placed on top of the lids; giving it a more crunchy flavor. Remember, you may eat the lids (the red part) but not the stems of tomatoes (the green part). This is a safe practice always. See the blog post, "The "Scary" Tomato comes to Europe" for more about this.

12) Place the pan on a lower rack in the oven and cook at 180°C (350°F) for about 1½ hours, until done (the ripeness of the tomatoes determines the exact time, but 1½ hours is normally the perfect amount of time to cook the tomatoes and potatoes).

Turn off the oven and let the tomatoes rest in the oven. They can be eaten immediately but it’s nice to cook this dish early in the day and eat it later when all the flavors have had a chance to mingle.

Greek Stuffed Tomatoes ready to be eaten.
All done! And your kitchen smells fabulous, too.

 13) To serve: Serve with a dollop of strained Greek yogurt (or alternatively tofu yogurt to keep it a vegan dish), a drizzle of extra olive oil atop your plated tomato, and a bowl of seasonal fruit for dessert...

Greek stuffed tomatoes being plated and a drizzle of PJ Kabos EVOO being added at the end.
Now as you eat this, imagine yourself in the land of PJ Kabos, where the very olive oil in this dish originates!

Kali Orexi—Happy Eating!


Please see our sister site pjkabos.com for Greek Stuffed Tomatoes for Vegetarians & Vegans where the above iconic Greek Mediterranean dish is further showcased in a beautiful cooking reel.


A Selection of PJ Kabos High-Phenolic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

PJ Kabos Family Reserve Organic—"Phenolic Shot" (Gold Bottle)

PJ Kabos - "The Phenolic Shot." An elegant & protective gold bottle of PJ Kabos extremely high phenolic extra virgin olive oil.
PJ KABOS “Phenolic Shot” (1000+ mg/kg), 2024/25 Harvest, USDA Organic Greek Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Highly Bitter & Pungent Taste, Greece, Cold Extracted, 16.9 fl oz Bottle.
PJ Kabos Family Reserve Organic—"Phenolic Shot," is possibly the highest phenolic content available in a true extra virgin olive oil today. Meant to be taken as a shot or to drizzle over meals like salads, roasted vegetables, toast, fava, etc. to amplify both flavor and health benefits.
Be Prepared: Our '"Phenolic Shot" is not your average olive oil—it is highly intense, full-bodied, bitter and unapologetically powerful. But according to scientific studies (see our blog for articles on its health benefits) it is also very very good for you.

PJ Kabos Family Reserve Organic—Robust 

(Black Bottle)

An elegant black bottle of PJ Kabos High Phenolic Robust Extra Virgin Olive oil with olives scattered around it. A finishing oil, cooking and baking oil and a phenolic shot.
PJ KABOS 2024 Fresh Harvest, VERY HIGH PHENOLIC (600+ mg/kg), USDA ORGANIC Greek Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Kosher, Greece, Cold Extracted, 16.9 oz Bottle
PJ KABOS Family Reserve Organic - Robust, is an extra virgin olive oil that is very high in polyphenols and adds depth, character and great health benefits to every meal.

PJ Kabos Family Reserve Organic—Medium Taste 

(White Bottle)

An elegant white bottle of PJ Kabos Medium High Phenolic Extra Virgin Olive Oil with olives scattered around it. Finishing oil, cooking oil and a phenolic shot.
PJ KABOS 2024 Fresh Harvest, HIGH PHENOLIC (400+ mg/kg), USDA ORGANIC Greek Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Kosher, Greece, Cold Extracted, 16.9 oz Bottle
PJ KABOS Family Reserve Organic - Medium, is an extra virgin olive oil that is high in polyphenols and adds a lovely taste and great health benefits to every meal.

PJ Kabos Family Reserve—Medium Taste 

(White Tin)

A tin of PJ Kabos High Phenolic Medium Extra virgin Olive Oil. A finishing oil, cooking oil and a phenolic shot. It is easy to store.
PJ KABOS 2024 Fresh Harvest, High Phenolic (400+ mg/kg), Premium Greek Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Origin Greece, Kosher, Cold Extracted, 16.9 fl oz Tin
PJ KABOS Family Reserve - Medium, is an extra virgin olive oil in an easy-to-store tin that is high in polyphenols and adds a lovely taste and great health benefits to every meal.

Please enjoy having a look around our websites, pjkabos.com and oliveoil.com, as well as our Amazon Store for more about our many high-phenolic olive oils, recipes, history, etc. And follow along with us on Instagram for photos concerning olive oil production, our groves in Greece, articles about olive oil, family history and more.

PJ Kabos High-Phenolic Extra Virgin Olive Oil: Your Trusted Oil, Straight from Our Table to Yours.